Child Abuse and Neglect in Family

 

Yi Bae Keun (President, Korea Youth Counseling Institute)

児童虐待と家族のネグレクト

Child Abuse and Neglect in Family

 

イ・ベグン

韓国青年カウンセリング研究所長

                 Yi Bae Keun

 (President, Korea Youth Counseling Institute)

 

 リスト Back to list

 

I. Review on Child Protection in Korea

 

1. Legislation for Child Protection

 

  During the past decade, children's issues in Korea have come to an overarching policy and administration areas in a way to make a new start for the 21st Century. Legislation activities such as the Revised Child Welfare Law were the response to those manifold and magnified children's issues in changing family and society. In general, the majority of Korean children grow up in good material circumstances with their own parents, and school education and children's health are on the whole developing well. However, the economic crisis called IMF from 1997 to 2000 influenced badly to many children and their families. Korea has a long tradition of love and protection thoughts toward children, due to inheritance of Confucian sacrificial rite in a way to respect of ancestors.

   In Three Kingdoms days, King Yuri, the 5th King of Silla Dynasty in 28, enacted royal orders to care those children without parents or care-givers. King Sungjong of Korea Dynasty In 994 set up public system to take care those children at risk up to age of ten. King Chungjo, the 22nd king of Yi Dynasty in 1783 set up public systems for the abandoned and street children by legislation. However, modernized child care and protection institutions had been set on foot by Christian mission services since early in 1900's.

   Right after the liberation from Japan, the Child Labor Act was enacted and not a few laws regarding child welfare and protection child labour were enacted during the 1st Korean Republic Government to present Government  as follows;

 

   1) In the 1st and 2nd Korean Government periods; the Education Law in 1949, and the Labor Standard Law in 1953 were enacted. 

   2) In the 3rd and 4th Government Periods; in 1961, the Child Welfare law, the Livlihood Protection Law, and the Minor Protection Law were enacted. The School Health Law in 1967, the Mother and Child Health Law in 1973, and the Special Education Promotion Law in 1977 were legislated. 

   3) In the 5th and 6th Government periods; in 1981, the Revised Child Welfare Law, the Welfare Law for the Handicapped, and the Infant Education Promotion Law were enacted. The Youth Upbringing law in 1987, and the Infants and Preschoolers Nursing Law in 1991 were legislated.

   Recently legislating the Family Violence Prevention Law in 1998, the Youth Protection Law in 1999 and the Revised Child Welfare Law in 2000 included prevention, intervention, identification and treatment of child abuse and neglect came to mark a new era of child right in Korea.  According to the Revised Child Welfare Law, reporting system. intervention to the suspecting and or abusing family, separation the abused children from their parents, court orders to the abusers and other activities came to be available by legal procedures.

 

2.  Child Love and Protection Movement

 

   In 1921, one year before Eglantyne Jebb in U. K. announced Child Rights, Korean civic movement to love and protect the children were risen spontaneously by Cheondoism (a Korean rooted religion) as well as educated leaders of the society. In accordance with the movement, Children's Day was set up in 1923 and May 5th could be a national holiday. In 1957 Children's Charter was enacted, and it was revised in 1988. International Year designated by UN for Children (1979), for the Handicapped(1981), and International Year for the Youth(1985)  pushed forward improvement of child and youth services programs by the government and NGOs to a degree.

   As far as advocacy and promotion of child rights, UNICEF Korea has carried out key roles by forwarding governmental ratification of Convention on the Right of the child(CRC), explaining CRC to school and the civic society, and organizing NGOs for implementation of CRC.

   In 1989 UNICEF Korea and Korea Welfare Foundation organized the Korean Association for Prevention of Child Abuse and Neglect (KAPCAN), and over fifteen years KAPCAN has developed systems, procedures and implementation of child right against child violence and child abuse including child exploitation. Good Neighbors has extended its prevention and treatment of child abuse programs on a nationwide since 1996. In 1983 Korea Child Protection Foundation set up Child-line and in 1999 established group home for the abused and neglected children and devoted to express the voice of children and youth as well as to protect those abused children.

   In 1991 Korea Council of Children's Organizations and in 1992 Korean Society for Child Welfare was established respectively to advocate and promote quality of child life. In 1995 Foundation for Preventing Youth Violence was established, and in 1997 Korean Society for Child Rights was set up by professors and professionals to study and develop child right programs and indicators, etc.  However, provision of systems and installation of 39 Central and Local Child Abuse Prevention Centers since 2000, in accordance with the Revised Child Welfare Law, were to be recorded as critical efforts by GO and NGOs for those children at risk.

 

II. The most recent Child and Family Issues

 

   Escape from poverty during 1960's and 1970's was the most major targets of family and society and as a result, Korea achieved the miracle of Han River. However, unstable social and political situations have brought about unwanted and unexpected economic crisis since late 1997. Since then, to overcome the big gap between the rich and the poor compare with to escape from the poverty in 1960's-1970's has come to be the most important social issues.

   The most recent child and family issues in Korea are notified as sudden drop of birthrate recorded 1.08 in 2006, increase number of children at risk including abused and neglected children, abandoned children, missing children, etc. Increase of aging population, family disorganization, jobless people and poverty stricken family are social issues related children.

 

1. Change of Family Structure and Decrease Number of Children

 

Table 1. Change of Family Structure (%)

 

1975

1980

1985

1990

1995

2000

Nuclear Family

71.9

73.1

73.3

74.1

73.7

72.9

Extended Family

21.1

18.2

16.3

13.9

11.6

10.2

Others

7.0

8.7   

10.4

12.8

14.7

16.9

                             Resource: Statistics of the Health and Social Affairs, 2006

 

   As shown above, nuclear family has increased from 71.9 percent in 1975 to 72.9 percent in 2000, while on the other, extended family with grandparents has decreased from 21.1 percent in 1975 to 10.2 percent in 2000. As a necessary consequence, it follows that the average numbers of family members has been decreased from 5.0 in 1975 to 2.9 in 2005 as under.

 

Table 2.  Average Number of Family Members

 

1975

1985

1995

2000

2005

Average Numbers of Family Members

5.0

4.2

3.7

3.1

2.9

                             Resource: Statistics of the Health and Social Affairs, 2006

 

   Change of family structure and average number of family members have an effect on the decrease of child population. Child population under 18 years of age has decreased from 46.3 percent among total population in 1975 to 24.2 percent in 2005. In family decrease of child population has brought about over child protection as well as over discipline, child fatness, and other problems.

 

Table 3.  Change of Child Population (unit: 1,000)

 

1975

1985

1990

1995

2000

2005

Total Population

35,281

40,806

42,869

44,851

47,008

48,294

Child Population

16,351

15.013

14,489

12,800

12,904

11,689

Rate of Child

population (%)

46.3

36.8

33.8

28.5

27.5

24.2

                            Resource: Statistics of the Health and Social Affairs, 2006

 

2.  Increase of Divorce Rate

 

   In recent, rapid change of family structure and increase number of nuclear family are basically caused by severe conflict of family members and increase the divorce rate. The National Statistical Office reports per couple of 17 couples in 1983, 7 couples in 1993 and 3.5 couples in 2000 divorced. 

   In 2005, total of 128,500 couples divorced, the means age of divorce was 40 years of age for men and 37 years of age for women, and 70 percent of the divorced couples had children under 20 years.  

 

Table 4.   Trends of Divorce Rate

 

1980

1990

1995

2000

2005

No. of divorce (unit: 1,000)

23.7

45.7

68.4   

120.0

128.5

Crude Divorce Rate (CDR)

0.6

1.1

1.5

2.5

2.6

                 Resource: The Ministry of Health and Social Affairs, 2006

  

   In addition to the increase of divorce rate, remarriage rate is also increasing. The remarriage rate was 10.0 percent of men and 10.0 percent of women in 1995, however, 18.9 percent and 21.1 percent in 2005 respectively. Children are to be affected in adaption to their newly established family environment by the remarriage of their parents.

 

Table 5.  Trends of Remarriage Rate(%)

 

1995

1997

1998

1999

2000

2001

2002

2003

2004

2005

Men

10.0

10.6

11.6

12.8

13.1

14.7

15.4

16.5

18.2

18.9

`Women

10.0

11.3

12.5

14.0

14.5

16.4

17.2

18.3

20.4

21.1

                 Resource: The Ministry of Health and Social Affairs, 2006

 

3.  Children at Risk

 

   In the past, the right of bringing up children was the issue for the divorcing parents, on the while, in recent escaping responsibility of child care is a problem of the divorcing parents. The incidence of abandoned children, called social orphans, has been decreased rapidly since 1990's; 1,844 abandoned children in 1990, 429 in 2005. However, the number of children at risk including  the abused and neglected children in the statistics have been increased from 5,721 in 1990 to 9,420 in 2005.

   As to the placement of the children at risk, more than half of them were placed into residential care, mainly children's home rather than family care. However, the number of children placed into foster family care have been increased since 2004 as shown <Table 7>.  

  

Table 6.  Statistics on the Children at Risk

 

1990

1995

2000

2004

2005

Abandoned Children

1,844

1,227

1.270

481

429

Children of Unmarried Mothers

2,369

1.285

2,983

4,004

2,638

Missing Children

360

149

144

62

63

Family Disorganization,

Runaway children

1,148

1,915

1,757

581

1,413

 

 

 

 

4.265

4.877

Total

5,721

4,567

7,760

9,393

9.420

                 Resource: Statistics of the Health and Social Affairs, 2006

 

Table 7.  Statistics on the Placement of the Children at Risk

 

1990

1995

2000

2004

2005

Placed residential care facilities

3,734

2,819

4,453

4,782

4,818

Foster family care

1,134

505

1,406

2.212

2,322

Adoption

853

472

1,337

2,100

1,873

Placed as child headed family

 

 

 

299

407

Total

5,721

4,567

7,760

9,393

9,420

                Resource: Statistics of the Health and Social Affairs, 2006

 

4. Child Headed Family

 

   Since 1985, Korean Government had come to strengthen family based services for the needy children, and developed child-headed family services for the family consisted of children under 18 years of ages.  Child-headed family without parents or with physically or mentally handicapped parents  are to be subsidized by the Central and Local Governments for their living, schooling, etc. 

   A nation wide study (Yi Bae Keun, 1988) reported the incidence causes of child-headed family were death of parents (25.1%), death of father (57.8%), death of mother (4.2%) and divorce, etc. (12.9%).

   From middle of 1990's, the Ministry of Health and Social Affairs has developed group home program for the child headed family in a way to provide family like environment as well as to give professional supervision by care-givers. As of 2005, 4,332 children are in 2,755 child-headed families. Child-headed families have been on the decrease in number as follows;  

 

Table 8.    Statistics on Child-headed Families

 

Numbers

Child-headed Family

Numbers of Children

Numbers of children attending school

Pre-

school

Primary

school

Middle

school

High

school

Others

1985

4,941

6,224

 

 

 

 

 

1990

6,696

13,778

 

 

 

 

 

1994

7,540

14,372

124

3,026

4,940

3,892

2,390

1998

8,407

13,627

150

2,428

4,515

5,141

1,393

2000

6,229

9,579

121

1,862

3,217

4,041

338

2003

3,994

6,184

99

1,309

1,966

2,668

142

2005

2,755

4,332

85

901

1,343

1,923

80

                            Resource: Statistics of the Health and Social Affairs, 2006

 

III.  Child Abuse and Neglect in Korea

 

    Even though no fully accurate figures are available to judge the nation-wide incidence and prevalence of child abuse in Korea, physical abuse has been decreased in family and school settings from limited studies and research so far as follows;

   An incidence survey of battered child of the two elementary schools in Seoul (Bock Ja Ko,1991) reported 86.4 percent of the total responded experienced  battering their  family members and 23.9 percent was identified as severe cases.

   Another small-scale nation wide survey(Yi Bae Keun, 1993) reported 78 percent of the responded parents battered their children. The reasons they battered their children were disobedience (41.1%), sibling quarrel (21.4%) and neglecting their learning (14.3%).

   A case study in 1996 by Good Neighbors reported 61.4 percent was physical abuse, 42.0 percent emotional abuse, 36.7 percent neglect, and 14.5 percent  was sexual abuse of the total responded 597 cases.

  Korea Health and Social Institute reported approximately 508,000 children were suffering from various types child abuse and neglect by its randomly sampled survey in 1996.

   Research on child abuse in 2000 by Child line of Korea Child Protection Foundation reported age group from 8 to 10 years old was 25 percent, from 4 to 7 was 24 percent, and from 11 to 13 was 18 percent. 

   On the while, statistics of 2006 says 4,633 children were reported as abused and neglected children in 2005. Of the total, 36.9 percent is duplicated abuse, 35.3 percent neglect, 11.1 percent emotional abuse, 9.1 percent physical abuse, 4.4 percent sexual abuse, 3.2 percent abandoned. Types of child abuse were;

 

Table 9.   Types of Child Abuse (Number of children (percent))

 

2001

2002

2003

2004

2005

Physical abuse

476(22.6)

254(10.3)

347(11.9)

364(9.4)

423(9.1)

Emotional abuse

114(5.4)

184(7.4)

207(7.1)

350(9.0)

512(11.1)

Sexual abuse

86(4.1)

65(2.6)

134(4.6)

177(4.5)

206(4.4)

Neglect

671(31.9)

814(32.8)

965(33.0)

1.367(35.1)

1,635(35.3)

Abandonment

134(6.4)

212(8.6)

113(3.9)

125(3.2)

147(3.2)

Multiple abuse

623(29.6)

949(38.3)

1,155(39.5)

1.508(38.8)

1,710(36.9)

Total

2,105(100)

2,478(100)

2,921(100)

3.891(100)

4,633(100.0)

                           Resource: Statistics of the Health and Social Affairs, 2006

 

  

   With respect to the place where the abuse and neglect occurred, total of 4,633 children reported in 2005 as abuse and neglect family was 77.5 percent, and this means most child abuse and neglect cases are occurred in family as under;

 

Table 10.  Place where Child Abuse and Neglect occurred

Place where child abuse and neglect occurred

Numbers of children

Percent

In family

3,589

77.5

Near home or on the street

253

5.5

Relatives home

84

1.8

Neighbours

55

1.2

Nursery care room

19

0.4

Day care center

65

1.4

Kindergarten

6

0.1

School

44

0.9

Educational institute

24

0.5

Hospital

51

1.1

Welfare institution

97

0.4

Unknown

19

0.4

Others

327

7.1

Total

4,633

100

                             Resource: Statistics of the Health and Social Affairs, 2006

                            

    As to statistics on age of the abused and neglected children in 2005, of the total 4,633, children in 10-12 years of age was 25.8 percent, 7-9 was 22.9 percent, and 13-15 was 18.3 percent. Regarding to gender, 2,353(50.8%) was boys and 2,280(49.2%) was girls, and so there was no discrepancy between boys and girls.

 

Table 11.  Age of Abused and Neglected Children

Age

under 1

1-3

4-6

7 - 9

10 -12

13- 15

16 - 18

Unknown

Total

Children

132

374

681

1,062

1,197

849

334

4

4,633

Percent

2.9

8.1

14.7

22.9

25.8

18.3

7.2

0.1

100

                             Resource: Statistics of the Health and Social Affairs, 2006

 

                   

 

Table 12.  Types of the Abused and Neglected Children's Family

 

Numbers of children

Percent

General family

1,173

25.3

Motherless family

1,559

33.7

Fatherless family

659

14.2

Unmarried parents

85

1.8

Remarried family

317

6.8

Relatives

283

6.1

Illegal living together

227

4.9

Foster home

29

0.6

Adopted family

17

0.4

Institutional care

88

1.9

Child-headed family

26

0.6

Unknown

78

1.7

Others

92

2.0

Total

4,633

100

                       Resource: Statistics of the Health and Social Affairs, 2006

            

    As shown above, motherless family was 33.7 percent and fatherless family was 14.2 percent of the total 4,633 abused and neglected children in 2005. This means almost half of the total family with child abuse and neglect was disorganized family.

    With respect to the types of abusers, father was 55.2 percent, mother 23.7, step father 0.8, step mother 3.1, and adopt parents was 0.6 percent, Table 13 shows most of the abusers, 83.4 percent of the total, was parents.

 

Table 13.  Types of the Abusers

 

Type of Abuser

Number of Abuser

Percent

Parents

Father

2.554

55.2

Mother

1,098

23.7

Step father

38

0.8

Step mother

142

3.1

Adoptive father

15

0.3

Adoptive mother

15

0.3

Sub total

3,862

83.4

Grand parents, Relatives,

Others

Grand parents

141

3.1

Relatives, sibling

209

4.5

Teachers, neighbors, others

421

9.0

 

Total

4,633

100

                        Resource: Statistics of the Health and Social Affairs, 2006

 

    Table 14 shows gender and age groups  of the abusers. In gender, men were 64.5 percent and women were 34.6 percent, and 0.9 percent was unknown. Male abusers were  almost double more than female. As to the ages of the abusers, 40-49 years of age was 40.2 percent, 30-39 was 33.0 percent. In general, 30 -49 years of age group was 73.2 percent of the total abusers, and so the most dangerous age group.

 

Table 14.   Gender and Age Groups of the Abusers

 

 

Number of abuser

Percent

Sex

Male

2,984

64.5

Female

 

 

Unknown

 

 

 

Age groups 

Under19 years of age

52

1.1

20 - 29 years of age

289

6.2

30 - 39

1,529

33.0

40 - 49

1,862

40.2

50 - 59

349

7.5

60 - 69

105

2.3

Over 70 years of age

36

0.8

Unknown

411

8.9

 

Total

4,633

100

                        Resource: Statistics of the Health and Social Affairs, 2006

                  

    As to the economic statues, abusing family under 1.5 million Won of monthly income was over 50 percent of the total, therefore, poverty is one of significant factors of intra-familial child abuse and neglect as Table 15 shows us.

 

 

 

Table 15.  Economic Statues of the Abusing Families

Means monthly income

Number of family

Percent

None or under 0.5 million Won

1,136

24.5

0.5 million - one million Won

747

16.1

one million - 1.5 million Won

461

10.0

1.5 million - 2 million Won

231

5.0

2 million - 2.5 million Won

97

2.1

2.5 million - 3 million

45

1.0

Over 3 million

38

0.8

Unknown

1,878

40.5

Total

4,633

100

                             Resource: Statistics of the Health and Social Affairs, 2006

 

 

 

IV. In Familial Child Abuse and Neglect in Korea as   Family Violence

 

   We are supposed to feel safe at home. Home should be where children are loved, protected, and restored after school. For many children, however, the home is not a safe haven from the family violence. Instead, it is a dangerous place where mental, physical, or sexual suffering occurs, often on a regular basis.

   Child abuse and neglect are global phenomena. In every society and in every period of human history, children have been subjected to some forms of abuse and neglect. In terms of definition and scope, child abuse has been extended from baby battered syndrome, a limited age and type of abuse, to physical and psychological abuse and neglect, and lastly to maltreatment, that is to say, a comprehensive conception and scope.

   Early in 1960's, Kempe defined the intra-familial child abuse and neglect as "Any child who received non-accidental physical injury as a result or guardians." Middle of 1980's, ISPCAN(International Society for the Prevention of Child Abuse and Neglect) specified child abuse and neglect as intra-familial child maltreatment - distinguished into physical, emotional, sexual abuse, and extra-familial child maltreatment - distinguished into institutional child abuse, neglect, exploitation of child labour, sexual abuse including child prostitution.

   Today, child abuse and neglect, especially in family, have become an increasing social issues in Korea. The legislation of the revised Child Welfare Law in 2000 included reporting system and operation of Regional Prevention Centers against Child Abuse was a milestone for intervention of the governmental authorities as well as civic society into prevention and treatment of child abuse and neglect. Since then reporting cases have been dramatically increased, mainly from family, however, prevention and treatment policy for the child abuse and neglect in family including urgent intervention and separation the abused children from the abusing parents are very weak.

    As mentioned above, 77.5 percent of the total abused and neglected cases were from family; only 25.3 percent was family with parents, and one-parent family was 45.9 percent. Of the abusers, 83.4 percent was parents and of them, 55.2 percent was fathers and 23.7 percent was mothers. As to factors related with economic status, 50.6 percent of the total family was under 1.5 million Won of monthly income, on the other hand, that of over 3 million Won was only 0.8 percent of the total. 

   As a result, most of child abuse and neglect occurs in family, and motherless and fatherless family are high in incidence of child abuse and neglect. Parents are the major parts of abusers, and poverty is one of significant factors for child abuse and neglect.

   A recent study on the intra-familial child abuse and neglect by Prof. Jeon Sun Young reported the characteristics of the abusers as follow;

 

 

 

 

 

Table 16.  Characteristics of the Abusers

Characteristics

Number of abusers

Percent

Personality problems

663

10.2

Experience of abuse when he was young

122

1.9

Alcoholic and drug abuse

631

9.7

Physical and mental handicapped, mental illness

379

5.8

Unwanted baby

108

1.7

Maltreatment

1,166

17.9

Insufficiency of parenting skill and knowledge

838

12.9

Marital conflict

485

7.4

Stress

338

5.0

Social isolation

305

4.7

Economic problem

643

9.9

Spouse violence and ascendant abuse

363

5.6

Man with criminal record

96

1.5

Religious problem

35

0.5

No specific characters

38

0.6

Unknown

202

3.1

Others

106

1.6

Total

6,507

100

 

   As to characteristics of the abusers in family, maltreatment of parents was 17.9 percent, insufficiency of parenting skill was 12.9 percent. As a result, parenting skill, attitude, knowledge are critical to prevent parents from child abuse and neglect in family, and so parent education parenting skill, parent counselling, after care, follow-up should be emphasized.  

   Other charateristics of the abusers were personality problems(10.2 %), alcohol and drug abuse(9.7%), marital conflicts(7.4%), physical and mental illness(5.8%),  spouse violence and ascendant abuse(5.6%), stress(5.0%), experience of abuse when he was young(1.9%), and religious problem(0.5%). Professional counseling service and treatment program should be provided for those cases.

   Lastly in case of economic problems(9.9%) and social isolation(4.7%), financial support, community networking and finding community resources services might be connected to the cases.

 

 

V. Program Planning against Child Abuse and Neglect

 

1. Empowerment of the Parents

 

   Empowerment of the parents will be critical to solve the problems with respect of child abuse and neglect in family, therefore, formal and non-formal parents education regarding child care, child growth and development, child psychology, health, nutrition, resource finding and other parenting skills should be expanded.

   As a social safety net, social insurance and public assistance programmers are to carry out key role for empowerment of the parents. Therefore, governmental authorities should develop supporting systems and programs not only for the family with children at risk but also all the family with vulnerable and general children in a way to bringing up the children healthy and soundly. 

   Lastly parents for themselves should willingly take part in voluntary activities to protect their children in the community.

 

2. Building up early intervention and prevention system for child abuse and neglect as Governmental policy and program planning

 

   As an integration supporting services for prevention child abuse and neglect and child health counseling, networking between child protection services and home visiting nurse system for the vulnerable families, is to be pretested as pilot project in 2006 - 2007, and will be implemented as national scale from 2008.

 

3. Establishing integrated child protection system and strengthening efficiency

   Set up fundamental integrated system for prevention and early intervention of child abuse and neglect is to be provided sooner, in a way to network possible public and private community resources like health post, community child welfare center, school, religious facilities, hospital, etc. In order to heighten efficiency of child protection system, professional services of child protection centers, increase the number of professional child protection worker and development of coping skills in accordance with types of physical abuse, sexual abuse, etc. are to be planned.

 

4.  Public relations for the prevention of child abuse and neglect  

 

   Strengthening public relations for the prevention of child abuse and neglect through broadcasting TV, radio and other media, and producing poster are provided. Education and public relations with respect to the types of child abuse and neglect, and education for the parents as abusers are to be implemented.

 

5. Building up early intervention and protection system for the missing children

  

   Canvassing corporate to support public advertisement and mobile services, periodical evaluation of the unregistered child care facilities, and strengthening public relations to heighten social understanding on missing children are to be planned.